What are Income Clubbing Provisions and Tax Implications

September 23, 2009 · 23 comments

I have invested some money in Fixed Deposit in name of my wife’s name , She is not earning any thing right now , Will she have to pay tax on this ? . This is a innocent questions because of inadequate knowledge of Tax Provisions on Clubbing of Income . Let us see some Must know tax rules in area of Clubbing of Income .

Top rules of Clubbing of Income

  • Income of a minor child is added to husband or Wife’s Income , depending on whose total income is greater. So if Child earning is 1 Lacs and Wife is earning 5 lacs and Husband is earning 4 lacs , Child income will be added to Wife Income and it will be 6 lacs of income for Wife and taxed accordingly . Do you think you can live with 90% of your Salary ?
  • If you invest money in your Minor Child or Spouse name , All the income happening from that investment will be clubbed into your income . the main thing is who ever is the original owner of money will be taxed .

Exception : Income of a minor child shall not be clubbed and is taxable if the child is suffering from a disability (under Section 80U) such as physical disability, complete blindness or if he earns the income through manual work or any activity involving application of his skills or talent or if both his parents are not alive.

  • The compounded income is not subject to clubbing . Which means that the income arising from the income which is clubbed is not clubbed . So If Ajay invests 30 Lacs in an FD on his Wife Name , Suppose the Interest on this FD comes to be 2.4 Lacs and The interest arised from this FD will be included in Ajay income , but any income which comes from this interest of 2.4 lacs will be considered as his Wife income and not Ajay income and hence will not be clubbed back to Ajay’s income . So if his Wife uses this 2.4 lacs and makes an income of 1 lacs . This 1 Lac will not be considered and clubbed in Ajay’s. Do you know How to find the Best Fixed deposit ?

[ad#big-banner]

Some Tips Use can use to save Tax

#1 : For High Net Worth Individuals

If you are a High Net worth Individual and your Spouse does not Work , you can make investment on his/her name , So that the income which comes from the income arised from that investment is alteast not taxed .

Example : If Robert invests 50 Lacs in Stocks and Earns 20 Lacs , It will be considered as His income and Taxed and now if he invests this 20 Lacs in FD , all the Interest he gets is also taxed . But If he Invests this 50 lacs on his Wife name , the 20 Lacs income generated will be taxed as his income , but then when that 20 lacs is invested in FD , all the interest coming from that will be treated as Wife income and If Wife is not doing anything , Her Total income will just be this interest , around 1.6 Lacs considering 8% interest and hence It will not be taxable at all as its below the limits .

jagoinvestor on Facebook

#2 Invest on your would-be-Wife or Son’s-Would-be-Wife name

Tax Clubbing rules does not apply when You invest money on some one’s name before Marriage (only yours would-be and Son-would-be , not your-friends-would-be) . So Any income arised from that investment will not be clubbed with your Income .

Example : If Manish is going to be married (thanks you guys) and He wants to invest 20 Lacs in an FD . He can do a simple tax trick , He can invest this money on his would-be-wife name. Now by doing so , all the interest coming from this FD will be considered as his wife Income and if her total income comes under minimum limit , She will not pay any tax on this . Where as If he invest this 20 Lacs on his own name or in his wife name after marriage , The interest will be taxed .

#3 Make sure the Investment on your Child Matures after their 18th Birthday

Clubbing Rules applies only for Minor Child’s , Its not applicable for Children above 18th . So make sure your Investments on Child Name mature after they are 18th , so that any income which arise from it is not your income . Read why you should open a PPF account even if you dont need it .

Example : So if you have a child aged 12 and you are planning to buy a Bond for 5 yr on this name , It will mature when child is 17 and hence will be taxed in your hand , better extend the Tenure by 1 yr and make it to 6 yr or 6.5 yr, so that The income arised from it is Child income and not taxed in your Hands .

#4 Give a Loan to your Spouse or Child , not a Gift

Clubbing Rules does not apply for genuine Loans Given to your Spouse or Child . So instead of just Gifting some money or Doing investment on their name , give Loan to them which they can use to invest them self , All the income from those investments will not be clubbed in your income. Make sure that you have a documentary proof of Loan , A simple letter of Loan with Signatures of both the party will be enough as Documentary Proof , no need to run for Lawyers for these .

#5 Create a HUF for Family investments and Family Properties

If you have a Joint or Big enough Family , Its better to Create a HUF , so that then all the investment which are for whole family and all the assets which belong to whole Family are on HUF name , in that case HUF will enjoy all the Deductions and exemptions just like an Individual . I don’t have much idea about HUF more than this .. so please control yourself before shooting detailed questions on HUF :) .

Conclusion

Knowing Clubbing of Income rules can help you in saving your Tax in different ways and Without the knowledge you may also loose many times . So better use these Tax rules to make best use of your situation .

Note : There are many exceptions and details in Clubbing Rules which are not covered here , These are just high level rules and not detailed rules . So please handle with Care . For more Tax related Articles , Visit Taxguru.in

If you Liked the post , Subscribe Here and get the posts directly in your Inbox

Subscribe via RSS or Email:

{ 20 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Praveen Kumar September 24, 2009 at 12:09 am

Regarding your following statement:
QUOTE
Example : So if you have a child aged 12 and you are planning for a 5 yr on this name , It will mature when child is 17 and hence will be taxed in your hand , better extend the FD by 1 yr and make it to 6 yr or 6.5 , so that The income arised from it is Child income and not taxed in your Hands .
UNQUOTE

Incase of an FD even if the accumulated interest is paid at the maturity time, its my understanding that you have to pay tax for provisional interest earned.

I am sure this is the case atleast if the FD is opened on your name (not your child's name), if the provisional interest accrued for the financial year needs to be taxed. Infact the banks will detect TDS if it crosses the threshhold (it was Rs 5k earlier and now its Rs 10k starting this AY).

I think this is because the interest acrrued is used as principal for next term for interest earning compounded interest rate.

Reply

2 Padmanabhan V. K. January 31, 2011 at 5:00 pm

This depends on the bank you are opening the FD in. For example, SBI, ICICI, etc. calculate interest (and deduct TDS if applicable) on accrual basis. However Indian Bank treats the full interest as earned only on maturity and includes no interim interests in their calculations.

Reply

3 sumi September 24, 2009 at 1:32 am

It needs a lot of work to manage taxes in this manner. Very helpful. Usually people get so used to investing in one form and following a set pattern with their money they don't actively manage their money and taxes. Simply written.

Reply

4 Manish Chauhan September 24, 2009 at 1:44 am

@Praveen Kumar

Ahh .. I think you are correct .. I was suppose to write about Bonds or some other thing there , FD will be a wrong product there .

thanks for the mention .. I will change it ..

@Sumi

thanks :)

Manish

Reply

5 Krishna November 25, 2009 at 12:12 pm

HI,

This article is very useful. But, I have one doubts. You said one can invest in would-be’s name. But, how you can give that money, is it a gift?

Thanks,
Krishna
.-= Krishna´s last blog ..SBI Reduced Term Deposit Interest Rates =-.

Reply

6 manish November 25, 2009 at 3:54 pm

yes , through a gift deed .

Manish

Reply

7 satish December 30, 2009 at 10:57 am

Hello,
Nice article. Any income generated out of the money gifted by me to my mother, will it be clubbed to my income and taxed or will it be clubbed to my mother’s total income and taxed(if applicable)?

regards,
satish

Reply

8 manish December 30, 2009 at 3:09 pm

it will be added to your income .. so better show it as “Loan” ..

Manish

Reply

9 satish December 30, 2009 at 4:47 pm

Thanks Manish for the quick response, Thats looks good to me. Is there a minimum percentage(SB retrs) for the loan or can it be zero pecentage also? And how can I go about it to make it legal(stamp paper/notary etc)… Thanks in advance..

regards,
satish

Reply

10 manish December 30, 2009 at 9:10 pm

Even a written statement on piece of plain paper with signature would be legally binding ..

I am not sure if there is any minimum percentage you have to use .. but i think you can put some 3-4% atleast .. just that it will be then added to your income and be taxed ..

Manish

Reply

11 Deepak Choudhary April 3, 2010 at 5:28 pm

My wife who is a house wife, has PAN card and demat a/c in her name. I want to give loan to my wife so that she could invest in shares and mutual fund. It will be very kind of you if you could provide me the Format of giving loan.

Reply

12 Manish Chauhan April 3, 2010 at 5:43 pm

Deepak

I dont have much idea on this , however , you need to just write it on a plain piece of paper and signature .that is enough .

Manish

Reply

13 Pavan April 13, 2010 at 4:34 pm

Hey Manish,

This is in response to your response to Satish on December 30. Gifts given to mother will not be clubbed. Please refer to the folloing two links:

http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_lower-your-tax-liability-by-making-a-gift_1209393

http://www.rediff.com/money/2008/mar/12tax.htm

I understand we can give gifts to parents, children above 18 yrs and to siblings without breaking any provisions of clubbing of income. What say?

Reply

14 Manish Chauhan April 13, 2010 at 9:05 pm

Pavan

yea .. looks good . thanks for the links :)

Reply

15 Padmanabhan V. K. January 31, 2011 at 7:00 pm

Manish,

You have suggested gifting money to would-be-wife. However I guess receiving such money in aggregate of over Rs.50,000 per year (it used to be Rs.25,000 per gift from 1 Sep 2004 to 31 Mar 2006) is taxable as income from other sources. [http://law.incometaxindia.gov.in/DitTaxmann/IncomeTaxActs/2009ITAct/section56.htm]

Or can one say he is gifting it on the occasion of the marriage of the person he himself is marrying?

Reply

16 Manish Chauhan February 1, 2011 at 11:04 pm
17 Taxes4corrption March 2, 2011 at 8:51 pm

Yet an another example of how corruption begins with Indian Taxations. Income clubbing happens to be a legalized form of corruption by the government.

What we put in wife’s name is POST TAX, that is tax has already been paid for the income and the remaining becomes our savings.

Tax department treating what is already taxed and then given to loved ones as a “Evasion” is – just another unfair means for extraction.

Several countries allow joint filing of incomes by husband-wife couples. It is not the case in India. Shame that one has “loan” to a spouse. The closest equivalent for joint filing is Hindu Undivided Family.

The Family is already breaking up in India, and of course we have a tax system that only favours such break up.

The tax system has another form of corruption – Advance Tax. Tax which is for the financial year is collected in advance even before the year completes – while refunds are not given upto several years.

For a government ridden with scams, there is a Tax system that sure favours even more to come.

Reply

18 Uday January 2, 2012 at 11:52 am

Dear Manish,

I have been reading your blog from quite some time now…You are doing a really great job.

Need to know about Income tax stuff:

My parents have transfered Rs.7 Lacs to my account & I have been investing their money along with mine in the derivatives market & earning a decent profit of 4-5% every month.

What is the income-tax implication on the money given from my parents account into my account & the income generated through that money. Should i show it as a gift or as a loan from my parents.

I will repay them the entire money with say 20% interest within 2 yrs from now.

Awaiting for your feedback,

Thanks & Regards,

Uday

Reply

19 Manish Chauhan January 2, 2012 at 1:15 pm

Uday

Incase your parents gift the money to you , then the income generated will be yours only .. You can aslo show it as loan and then trasfer the money back to them later , but you will have to do some documention on this

Manish

Reply

20 Uday January 2, 2012 at 1:55 pm

Dear Manish

Thanks 4 ur immediate response. I am showing this as loan & will repay this in 2 yrs.

Is just writing it on a plain piece of paper and with my parents signature enough ?

Reply

Leave a Comment