POSTED BY December 19, 2013 COMMENTS (7)ON
Do you want to learn how money evolved in this world ? How did the concept of money took birth ? Today it might look very easy and intuitive to see and manage money, but it has long history and a very interesting one! . I always used to wonder about these topics, but got to read anything in detail untill some months back when Vivek Kaul sent me his book – “Easy Money – Evolution of Money from Robinson Crusoe to the First world war” (buy the book)
In this book, Vivek has shared how this world was first on the barter system and then slowly and steadily the concept of money was born. He mentions various events in history and examples which will how you how money was not just invented in a day, but it slowly took its shape because it was the need of the hour.
Kaul starts with the history of money from time immemorial and traces the development of money and the financial system till around the time of the end of the First World War. He tells us about the various commodities that have been used as money at various points of time. Other than gold and silver, a whole lot of other metals like copper, iron, platinum, lead, nickel, and tin, have been used as money by various civilizations at various points of time.
Other than metals, agricultural commodities like almonds, cacao beans, rice, wheat, and tobacco have also been used as money. In fact, tobacco was used as money in the United States longer than gold and silver were. Salt has been used as money in large parts of Sahara which are dry.
Here is one example sharing from the book
In the prisoner of war camps during the Second World War cigarettes were used as money. Dog teeth and dolphin teeth have been used as money. And in the island of Yap in the Pacific Ocean even large thick stone wheels called fei have also been used as money.
Gold is valueable because its “Useless”
One of the best things I learned from the book is that Gold is valuable in this world, because its Useless. Yes – you heard it right. From the start of my life, I used to wonder that why people love gold and why its so expensive when it cant be used for anything useful, and in the book I learnt that – its the exact reason why its so valuable . The book shares the reason for this and Here is an excerpt from the book
What also helped gold survive as money is its uselessness. “Despite the fact that it is highly malleable (can be beaten into sheets easily), ductile (can be easily drawn into wires), and the best conductor of electricity, gold does not have many industrial uses like other metals have. This is primarily because there is very little of it go¬ing around. Also, what does not help is the fact that gold is as soft as putty. This softness makes it practically useless for all purposes that need metal,” writes Kaul. “When commodities are used as money they are taken away from their primary use.
So, if rice or wheat is used as money for daily transactions and to preserve wealth, it means a lesser amount of rice and wheat in the market for people to buy and eat. This, in turn, would mean higher prices of grains, which are staple food in large parts of the world. Gold does not have many practical uses. So if people hoard gold, it does not hurt anyone,” he adds. Hence, gold survived as money largely till the start of the First World War. Then paper money took over as various European governments had to print money in order to finance the First World War.
Rise of Paper Money and Banking System
One of the most interesting points of Easy Money is the part where Kaul explains the close link between the rise of paper money and the banking system as it has evolved to this day. In fact, the paper money system was at the heart of the profitability of banks. As Kaul writes “The moral of the story is that the lesser the capital the bank had, the greater money it made, but greater was its chance of going bust as well. As Walter Bagehot, the great editor of The Economist once put it, “the main source of profitableness of established banking is the smallness of requisite capital.”
This is a very fundamental point on how the banks as well as other financial institutions have evolved over the years and is at the heart of things as they are currently. Banks as well as financial institutions over the years have figured out that the lesser the amount of capital they have on their books, the more money they make. But this increases the riskiness of the overall financial system as well.”
Note that the book also talks about some of the heavy topics like financial crisis, financial innovations like securitization, collateralized debt obligations, and credit default swaps, how banks evolved etc
The last chapter of the book tries to link the history to way things are happening currently. This chapter could have been little longer and ends a bit too quickly. Another thing that the author could have done is have had takeaways at the end of each chapter, linking them to the current financial crisis.
While I enjoyed the book, and its an an excellent read for anyone looking to understand the current financial crisis from a historical view point in simple jargon free English. Be clear that its not a regular personal finance book teaching you about concepts. Also be ready to read few things which you might not be able to digest in a single read. You should read the book only if you love the topic of money evolution and the whole idea which the book wants to present.
About Vivek Kaul
Vivek Kaul has worked at senior positions with the Daily News and Analysis (DNA) and The Economic Times. His writings have appeared across various other publications in India. These include The Times of India, The Times of India (Crest edition), The Hindu, The Hindu Business Line, The Pioneer, Indian Management, Asian Age, Deccan Chronicle, Forbes India, and Wealth Insight. He has also written regularly for www.rediff.com. Currently, he is a regular columnist for www.firstpost.com and a regular contributor to DNA.
Share with us how Jagoinvestor has helped you succeed in your financial life – Click Here
Here is the list of some of our best content.
2021 © Jagoinvestor.com All Right Reserved
7 replies on this article “Review of book – “Easy Money – Evolution of Money from Robinson Crusoe to the First World War””
The point about the uselessness of Gold is very ridiculous. I invite you to explore Mises’s explanation of how a commodity(any commodity, as there have been many that have been used as money) comes to play the role of money – and the primary requirement is that they should have some intrinsic use-value.
If it is data you’re looking for, pl confirm at the below historical data to see how even today majority of Gold is ‘used’ for some purpose other than as investment bullion.
Just based on this ridiculous assumption I am very apprehensive about the author’s knowledge about the issue he has covered.
The concept of growth of money has been very excellently covered by Nial Fergusson in his book, “The Ascent of Money”. It would be useful to potential readers if you could compare the two books in terms of the depth of subject covered. Nial’s book is a masterpiece on the topic, and by the above mentioned assumption, I wonder if it won’t be a better use of the time and money of any potential reader who’s interested in the topic.
Have you read the book by Vivek and the reasonings for gold worth ? I was personally convinced with it when i read it , just dont judge on one line which is “Gold is valuable because its worthless” , you need to read the full concept and how it evolved. You may still not be convinced, but then its about your understanding and ideology . Thats what I would say
Well explained Manish and Nandish…… Suresh.
All of this and much more is explained in a very simple video series in the below site:
Thanks for sharing that link 🙂
All of this is explained in very simple video series in the below site.
Since this topic is about Evolution of Money, or atleast the concept of money as we know it, please go through the link below (which has some interesting links) on the same concept.