Portfolio Management Suggestions

POSTED BY Sanchay Kulkarni ON January 13, 2011 4:24 pm COMMENTS (3)


My age is 31, married, no kids, dependent mother staying with me.

Income : 70k / month

Home Loan : 22K / month, 20 years remaining

Personal Loan : 6000 / month (18 months remaining, @16%), by pre-paying I will just save 4500// in all.

Liquid cash for emergencies : 60K

FDs : 1.5 Lac

PF contribution (self + company) = 6K/month

Insurance cover = 20 Lacs, LIC , + 25 Lac Term insurance, avg. premium/month = 3500/Month

Monthly expenses : 25K

Total expenses – 22K HomeLoan – 6000K Personal Loan – 25K Expensed – 3500 Insurance = 56500/month.

Amount remaining : 70,000 – 56,500 = 13500/month

I will probably work till age of 55, i.e. 24 years from now.


I searched through forums, and found many suggestions from Mr. Ramesh and

Please suggest me where should I invest my money? I want to save for my retirement. I was planning to invest 5000/month in MF equity SIP, 3500 bank recurring, 5000 Debts. Please suggest.


3 replies on this article “Portfolio Management Suggestions”

  1. Ramesh says:

    LIC endowment policy is to be calculated as debt (I would say 0.75 debt). Why? If I get 8% on a normal debt instrument over a long term, I would say LIC will provide about 6% over long term (if it is not a guaranteed return product). So calculate it accordingly. 🙂

    Personal Loan. A 5% pre-penalty almost means that you cannot fore-close it. But please go through the documents again. Usually, the prepayment charges decrease over time like 4% in first 6 months, 3% in next 1 year and 2% thereafter. something like that and please take an appropriate decision. I agree with your present calculations.

    current E/d = 0:100. Future E/d 60-70:20-40 is also perfect. But always remember, this E:D is about the total portfolio and not the present or future investments.

    Do not calculate the emergency fund in the portfolio. Keep it separate.

    So you should be investing more / almost completely in equity instruments till you get your ratio correct! If you invest 13500 per month, your E/D will be 2-5:95-98 in first few months/years and gradually increase.

    Also read this, http://www.subramoney.com/2011/01/which-pension-plan-to-buy-2/


    All equity and hybrid-equity funds, including ELSS, have ZERO tax after holding them for 1 year or more. So, they are the best tax-savers if you invest for long term.

    Regarding the MF which you should choose. That requires an entire new writeup. Though I have mentioned quite a few times. So just go through the forum about the recommendations and then we can proceed from there, if you do not understand or are unclear. 🙂

  2. Sanchay Kulkarni says:

    Hi Ramesh,

    Thanks for prompt response 🙂

    First of all, I messed up few (no many things) in stating insurance cover.

    1)Endowment policies insurance cover : Rs. 7,25,000/- only, in case of accidental health, its Rs. 9,25,000/-. Survival benefits, lumsum amount approx. Rs. 15,00,000
    2)Term Insurance-1 : Rs. 25,00,000/-
    3)Term Insurance-2 : Linked with HomeLoan

    1)PF : 6000/month (Debts)
    LIC Endowment Premiums : 2500/month (Debts ?)
    Equities : None,

    Current E/D ration 0:100

    2)I want to aim for for E/D ration of 60/40 or 70:30 (8500/- in Debts)

    3)Personal Loan, finer details: EMI 5668*18=102024, principal remaining = 91,000. Penaly 5% , if I forcelcose I need to pay, Rs. 95550. I save 1,02,024-95,500 = 6500 in 18 months, i.e. 360/month. Not sure if its worth closing it. (I can use FD amount for emergencies)

    Thanks for raising alarm for insurance cover, I need another insurance cover of 25,00,000/- ?? Please comment.

    Coming back to equities, If I invest 13,000/month savings into equities


    ratio would be 60:40

    If this looks ok, I need to know type of MF to invest in, the time period, tax implications port-return. As far as I know, all equity returns MFs are tax free ? is it correct ?
    what is best eay to save port-return taxes?

    Many thanks any advance.

  3. Ramesh says:

    You have provided a nice comprehensive information about your cash flow.

    Please go through my comments which I have posted in

    My suggestions:
    1. On that basis, calculate your current equity:debt ratio.
    2. Think about the equity:debt ratio which you should aim for.
    3. Include PF contribution to your debt contribution.
    4. Clarify your LIC policy. Is it an endowment policy / Ulip / term insurance? Is the term insurance policy taken as a collateral for your home loan. Then you can just keep it as a collateral for that liability. Re-evaluate your total insurance requirements.
    5. How much is the pre-payment penalty for your personal loan? A 16% personal loan is very expensive and considering the long duration of 16 months left (=16*6000=96000). You should prepay it using money from the FD (which will only earn 7-8% max).

    We can continue this discussion after this thought process. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Download Our FREE Ebook!

Available only for first 100 people today

Download Our FREE Ebook!

Available only for first 100 people today