review my investment option for shorter time. FD or debt fund ?

POSTED BY ainvest ON December 17, 2010 1:48 am COMMENTS (4)

I have 13-14 lacs available for investment. I might buy some property in another 1-2 years(not sure about exact time). Till that time I would like to invest this money. I am thinking of two options

1. Bank of maharashtra has FD with interest rate of 9% for senior citizens. My father is retired staff member of the bank so he will be getting 1% extra which makes it as 10% annual interest. So my father can put it in fixed deposit in his name(and me as nominee). His income(i.e. pension + annual FD interest) should not attract any tax(he will submit 15H form for the same). If I need the money in between I can break FD where there is only 1% penalty. in that case 9% interest also looks fine.

OR

2. To invest in one of the debt fund like Reliance MIP or HDFC MIP. Here the returns could be nice(11 or 12%) but there is little risk associated with it.

Please let me know readers view about my options or suggest other options

 

 

4 replies on this article “review my investment option for shorter time. FD or debt fund ?”

  1. Amol

    I am not sure how seriously you are looking at taxation , but as per clubbing rules of income tax , it does not work the way you think so .

    The interest earned out of the FD will not be his income, it would be YOUR income , because the source of the fund is you.

    Its a common myth that one can just invest the money in some one else name and the income arising out of that will be treated as the other person income , Tax rules do not support it . Offcourse you can do what you said saying that these small ticket transactions does not come under enquiries , but still just for your information I am telling you .

    I understand that this “Jugaad” will work in real life !

    Manish

  2. mkshahi says:

    FD for sure!! debt funds are not 100% risk free and can go down in short term as well. FD at 10% rate is very good for investment at this point of time.

  3. Elaya Kumar S says:

    I like to suggest the FD option for the following reason:

    a) attractive interest rate at 10% with nil tax liability;
    b) liquidity – since you may take the money from bank fd at any point of time with little loss.

  4. JayaprakashReddy says:

    I would suggest you to go with FD because couple of reasons.
    1. Expecting 10% return in short term investment anywhere other than FD is risky.
    2. Reliance and HDFC MIP’s have given negative return with short term.

    Getting 10% on FD is very rare through banks. I think its best to go with FD as it is always available for you anytime for withdraw.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Download Our FREE Ebook!

Available only for first 100 people today

Download Our FREE Ebook!

Available only for first 100 people today